The course · Undertone · Lesson 2 of 6 · 22 min
The lean is a hue angle, and neutral sits near 57 degrees
After this lesson you can turn a cheek's hue angle into steps of lean. You can also say where the neutral point of 57 degrees comes from, and why a published model uses a different anchor.

Nora's cheek reads at 66 degrees and Tess's at 48, and only Nora's looks golden.
Nora and Tess photograph their cheeks in even daylight beside white paper. Their skin is the same depth, so lightness cannot explain the gap. After correction, Nora's cheek reads at 66 degrees and Tess's at 48. Nora's looks golden beside the paper and Tess's looks rosy. The two numbers carry the lean.
A hue angle is the position of a color around the color wheel, measured in degrees.
In CIELAB, the hue angle is found from a* and b* with atan2, and it runs from 0 to 360 degrees. Chroma is the distance from the neutral center. Reading a lean means finding where the skin's hue sits on that circle. How light the skin is does not enter into it.
Neutral sits at 57 degrees because that is the midpoint of the 53 to 60 range in the consult model.
The anchor of 57 comes from the house consult model's own range, so it is a house number and not a standard. In beauty use, undertone is a description, not a single standardized measurement. When you explain the number to a client, say that 57 is the working anchor.
A published model centers warm and cool near 50 degrees, so any anchor is a stated choice.
One published warm-cool model uses a cosine around CIELAB hue angle 50 degrees and scales the result by chroma. Other published models use different formulas and datasets. A hue angle alone therefore gives no fixed warm or cool cutoff, and 57 is one anchor among several.
Each 6 degrees from 57 is one step of lean, and the band from 54 to 60 reads neutral.
The step count is U = (hue minus 57) divided by 6. Nora's 66 gives 1.5 steps warm. Tess's 48 gives 1.5 steps cool. Anything within half a step of 57, from 54 to 60 degrees, is neutral. Above half a step reads warm, and below minus half a step reads cool.
A hue angle is a coordinate, not a temperature, because CIELAB predicts hue imperfectly.
The author of the Oklab color space lists the inability to predict hue as the largest issue with CIELAB and CIELUV, and says blue hues are predicted badly. OKLCH's h works the same way, as a coordinate for hue. A warm or cool lean needs a rule that is stated, which is why the anchor is said aloud.
The method counts steps from 57, then checks the lean in the drape.
Two skins can share one angle and still differ in depth, because depth and lean are read apart. A dark skin at 57 degrees is neutral, and so is a light one. Light also moves the hue a camera records, so the method reads the cheek in even daylight beside white paper, and the drape confirms the count.
Figure
One depth step, five leans. Each square is a typical skin at depth step 3, from two steps cool on the left to two steps warm on the right. The grays match across the row; in color the warm squares read more yellow.
In their words
“In particular blue hues are predicted badly.”
Björn Ottosson, A perceptual color space for image processing
Check
Nora and Tess have the same depth. What differs between their cheeks?
Show the answer
A. Their hue angle
Lightness is the same, and the hue angle is not, 66 degrees against 48. The angle is what carries the lean.
Practice
Cheek A reads 69 degrees and cheek B reads 45 degrees, both at the same lightness. Using steps of 6 from 57, how do they read?
Show the answer
A. A is two steps warm, and B is two steps cool
The hue angle is the dimension that differs. A is 12 above 57, which is two steps warm, and B is 12 below, which is two steps cool. Equal lightness does not make them neutral, and the direction is not swapped.
Ana's cheek reads 58.5 degrees and Bea's reads 61 degrees, at the same depth. How do they read?
Show the answer
C. Ana is neutral, and Bea is warm
Ana is 1.5 degrees above 57, which is a quarter step, inside the neutral band of half a step. Bea is 4 above, two thirds of a step, which passes half a step, so she reads warm. Calling both neutral misses that Bea has crossed the band.
A client's cheek reads 51 degrees in one photo and 63 degrees in another taken by a window. How many steps did the reading move?
Show the answer
A. Two steps, which is a sign to recheck the light
Twelve degrees at 6 per step is two steps. A move that large between photos points to the light or the setup, and the lean is read in even daylight beside white paper. One step and six steps are miscounts.
A client's cheek reads 52 degrees. A published model centers warm and cool near 50. With the house anchor of 57, how does she read?
Show the answer
A. About one step cool, using the stated anchor
The anchor is the deciding choice. 52 is 5 below 57, which is 0.83 steps cool. The published model is a different model with its own formula, so it does not override the stated anchor. The anchors disagreeing does not make her unreadable.
Two clients both read 57 degrees. One has light skin and one has deep skin. Which statement is correct?
Show the answer
D. Both are neutral, since depth does not move the angle
Depth is the dimension that differs, and the angle is the same. The lean is the angle counted from 57, so both sit exactly at neutral. Depth and lean are read apart, so one does not shift the other.
Why does a hue angle alone give no fixed warm or cool cutoff?
Show the answer
B. Published models use different formulas and datasets
Warm-cool models differ in their formulas, anchors and observer data, so a cutoff must be stated, not assumed. CIELAB does compute a hue angle, and the angle is separate from lightness.
Case study 2
Priya, a nurse in her forties, wears silver because the veins at her wrist look green-blue. Her cheek, photographed in even daylight beside white paper and corrected, reads at 69 degrees. Her skin is medium.
Name her lean as a step count, and say what you confirm before you tell her.
Show the worked answer
Step 1: the wrist veins play no part. Step 2: count from the neutral point, 69 minus 57 is 12 degrees, and 12 divided by 6 is two steps. Step 3: two steps above 57 is warm. Step 4: gold against silver is a convention, so confirm the lean with peach against rose and warm white against cool white as well, and call it after two or three agree.